Should You Settle or Go to Court for a Personal Injury Claim in Missouri?

Finder Law Serves Clients Across Jefferson City, Columbia, and Central Missouri

July 8, 2025

When you're injured due to someone else's negligence, you may be entitled to compensation for your medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, and more. But once you've filed a personal injury claim, a key question arises: should you settle or should you go to court? Understanding the pros and cons of each option is essential to making an informed decision—and protecting your legal rights.

When Settling Makes Sense

Settling means resolving your case without going to trial, typically through negotiation with the at-fault party’s insurance company or attorney.


Benefits of settling include:



  • Faster resolution: Most settlements occur within months, whereas trials can drag on for years.
  • Lower costs: Avoiding court means fewer legal fees, filing costs, and expert witness expenses.
  • Predictable outcome: Trials come with risk; settling offers more control over the compensation you’ll receive. There will be no guess work in the amount you will receive.
  • Less stress: A courtroom battle can be emotionally and mentally draining, especially if you're still recovering from injuries.


In Missouri, most personal injury cases settle out of court for these very reasons. However, that doesn’t mean it’s always the right choice.

When Going to Court Makes Sense

There are situations when going to trial is the better—or only—option:


  • Lowball offers: If the insurance company refuses to offer fair compensation, going to court may be necessary to secure what you deserve.
  • Disputed liability: If the other side denies responsibility or blames you for the accident, a judge or jury may need to decide the matter.
  • Severe or complex injuries: High-value cases often involve expert testimony and legal complexity, making trial a more effective venue for full compensation.


In Missouri, courts apply a doctrine called comparative fault, which means your compensation can be reduced if you’re found partially at fault. Skilled trial representation is critical in these cases to argue for a fair allocation of blame.

What’s Best for You?

Every personal injury case is unique. Your best course of action depends on the strength of the evidence, the willingness of the other side to negotiate, and the value of your claim. Working with an experienced personal injury attorney ensures your case is positioned for the most favorable outcome—whether that’s a strategic settlement or a compelling courtroom presentation.

Call Finder Law, LLC for Expert Legal Representation ï»¿

If you’ve been injured and are wondering whether to settle or take your case to trial, don’t leave your future to chance. Contact Daniel Finder at Finder Law, LLC today for a free consultation. With extensive experience handling personal injury claims across Missouri, Daniel will fight to get you the compensation you deserve and advise you on the best way forward in your case.

This blog is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific guidance, please contact our office directly.

The “Laughing Heirs” in Missouri: What Happens When Remote Relatives Inherit?

August 26, 2025
Estate planning often focuses on spouses, children, and grandchildren. But what happens when someone dies without a will and without any close relatives? This is where the concept of “laughing heirs” comes into play.

When Should You Hire a Workers’ Compensation Attorney in Missouri?

August 19, 2025
If you’ve been injured on the job in Missouri, you’re likely dealing with pain, medical treatment, and the stress of lost wages. While workers’ compensation benefits exist to provide financial and medical support after a workplace injury, navigating the system can be complex and frustrating. Knowing when to hire a workers’ compensation attorney can make a significant difference in the outcome of your claim.

Personal Injury Claim FAQs in Missouri: What You Need to Know

August 14, 2025
If you’ve been injured due to someone else’s negligence, you may be considering a personal injury claim. Whether the incident involved a car crash, slip and fall, dog bite, or workplace accident, Missouri law provides a legal pathway for victims to recover compensation. Below, we answer some of the most frequently asked questions about personal injury claims in Missouri.

Do Grandparents Have Visitation Rights in Missouri?

August 12, 2025
Family relationships can be complex, and when parents separate or a child loses a parent, extended family members—especially grandparents—may wonder about their legal rights to remain in a child's life. In Missouri, grandparents do have potential visitation rights, but those rights are limited and only apply under specific circumstances.

Coping with Permanent Disabilities After an Accident in Missouri: Your Legal Options

August 7, 2025
Accidents can change your life in an instant—especially when they result in a permanent disability. Whether from a car crash, workplace injury, slip and fall, or other traumatic event, adjusting to a new way of life brings immense physical, emotional, and financial challenges. If you or a loved one has sustained a permanent disability in Missouri due to someone else’s negligence, you may be entitled to significant compensation. Here’s what you need to know about your rights and legal options under Missouri law.

The Impact of Domestic Violence on Child Custody in Missouri

August 6, 2025
When determining child custody in Missouri, the court’s paramount concern is always the best interests of the child. One of the most serious factors that can influence custody decisions is domestic violence. If you're navigating a custody dispute involving allegations of abuse, understanding how Missouri law addresses these situations is essential.

Exploring Alternatives to Jail and Prison in Missouri: A Path Toward Rehabilitation

July 29, 2025
In the Missouri criminal justice system, incarceration has long been the traditional response to criminal offenses. However, increasing awareness of the limitations and costs associated with jail and prison sentences has led courts, lawmakers, and advocates to explore alternative approaches that emphasize rehabilitation, reduce recidivism, and alleviate overcrowded facilities. This post explores some of the key alternatives to incarceration currently available or emerging in Missouri, providing valuable insight for defendants, attorneys, and concerned citizens.

My Spouse Just Asked for a Divorce in Missouri – What Should I Do?

July 24, 2025
Few phrases hit as hard as hearing your spouse say, “I want a divorce.” Whether or not you saw it coming, this moment can feel emotionally overwhelming and legally confusing. While every situation is unique, there are important steps you can take right away to protect your rights, your well-being, and your future.

Understanding Trespassing Laws in Missouri: What You Need to Know

July 22, 2025
Trespassing is a criminal offense that involves entering or remaining on someone else's property without permission. In Missouri, trespassing laws are designed to protect property owners' rights while balancing the public's right to access land in certain situations. Whether you're a property owner, a potential trespasser, or simply curious, it's important to understand how trespassing laws apply in the Show-Me State.

Pedestrian Accidents in Missouri: A Guide to Personal Injury Claims

July 17, 2025
Introduction